Friday, February 22, 2008

Does Spirituality Affect Behavior?

Last Tuesday I attended an interesting lecture on Hinduism and Catholicism at Loyola Marymount University. The lecture was given by Daniel L. Smith-Christopher who is a Professor of Old Testament and Director of Peace Studies at Loyola, and also by Graham Schweig who earned his doctorate in Comparative Religion from Harvard University and is currently Associate Professor of Religious Studies at Christopher Newport University in Virginia.

The lecture focused on exploring themes of war and peace found in the Old Testament and also in the Bhagavad Gita, the ancient religious texts used in Christianity and Hinduism.

Professor Smith spoke first, and he immediately stated that in the interest of "full disclosure", he told the audience how he was born a Quaker and was raised a Quaker, and that he emphatically believes that killing is wrong. To a peace activist like myself, this was music to my ears. I looked around and saw many nodding their heads in agreement. Clearly, this was a friendly audience made up of what looked to me like priests, Hindus, peace activists, and yogis. Professor Smith discussed a few stories from the Old Testament, and he made the point that the Old Testament was not intended for ethical instruction or military strategy, but is largely allegorical and symbolic. He also touched upon the "just war" theory, and pointed out that this theory was based more on Roman politics and not on scripture.

Next Professor Schweig spoke about the Bhagavad Gita and how it is a 700 verse subtext of the larger text the Mahabharata, but that the Bhagavad Gita is often read as an independent text. He describesd how in the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna is the main speaker while Sanjaya is the narrarator. Professor Schweig, who recently published his own translation of the Bhagavad Gita, interpreted many of the individual verses. He explained that one of the main themes found in the Bhagavad Gita surrounds the idea of conflict and how there will always be conflict in the world. He stated that the question is not how do we get rid of conflict but how do we process it? Do we process conflict towards violence or peace? Professor Schweig expressed the idea that conflict is part of humanity learning how to love, and that conflict can lead to either dissolution or resolution.

After both professors spoke, there was time for questions from the audience. The first question came from a man asking the professors to explain the Hindu idea of reincarnation versus the Christian idea of the soul. Professor Schweig said that one difference is that in the reincarnation belief system, we get more than one chance to get it right in that we are not doomed to hell based on one immoral life but get to have another chance in multiple lives. This was contrasted with the Christian idea of having one chance to live a moral life which will determine whether one spends eternity in heaven or hell.

This prompted a couple of women from the audience to raise the idea that there are words in the Bible that hint at the idea of reincarnation, and that because the Bible has been frequently altered and edited by various popes and leaders of the Church over time, that it is difficult to truly rule out the idea of reincarnation in the Christian faith. Professor Smith strongly responded that this is an uphill argument in the Christian fatih.

Another concept that arose during the questions and answers was the sanskrit term ahimsa, which translates to "Harm none" or nonviolence and is a tenet of yogic philosophy. Members in the audience and also both professors clarified that there are different levels of violence and ahimsa asks us to reject all levels of violence. Professor Schweig reminded the audience how we are called to practice ahimsa even at the level of conversation, and that we should strive to speak with others in a nonharmful peaceful way.

This led me to reflect on my own life and the way in which I converse with others including my family, neighbors, friends, colleagues, and yes, even in the blogosphere. Am I able to practice ahimsa when conversing with someone I disagree with? Can I clearly voice my views but in a nonviolent way? How about when I am tired and low on patience or angry, do I still practice ahimsa? Truly practicing ahimsa at every level is indeed challenging.

In psychology class we learned that psychology is the study of behavior and mental processes. Attending this lecture has caused me to reflect on the way in which one's spirituality affects one's behavior. In my case, my spiritual beliefs affect every aspect of my life including relationships, career, diet, political beliefs as well as every purchase I make.

My question is: do you believe that one's spiritual beliefs affect one's behavior and if so,in what ways does spirituality affect behavior? Feel free to speak from your own spiritual beliefs and experiences if you like.

13 comments:

Allie Maslyk said...

In many ways I do think one's spirituality affects their behavior. A lot a people do things based on their spiritual beliefs, but at the same time they do things based on human nature and their nurture, or how they are raised and taught. Like you said, in the Quaker religion, people are taught that killing is wrong, and I think this greatly affects their behavior, and this is because their spiritual beliefs are influencing them. Although many spiritual beliefs affect people in a positive way, they affect some people in a negative way. Even though this is true, it is very sad and unfortunate. Some people feel and believe that women are inferior to men. This is because they either grew up hearing it from their parents, or they really believe it is true. They think that women cannot do as many things as men, and that they can't and shouldn't have the same opportunities.

Unknown said...

To me, using spirituality to justify the idea that women are inferior to men is a misinterpretation and distortion of religious texts. I believe that all ancient religious texts need to be interpreted within a historical context. I'm glad you brought this up Allie.

August Samie said...

I honestly haven’t met anybody who is not influenced in regards to their behavior by their spiritual beliefs. I have, however, met people who claim to be of a certain faith, but don’t act according to their supposed belief system. Those who do practice a chosen religion do in fact act based on the moral merits directed by their religion.
Considering my own life, I’ve chosen to follow the guidelines of a religion that many people don’t approve of. My sister and I were raised as Catholics, attending church and doing the whole “Jesus thing,” but it wasn’t right for either of us. My parents escaped religious oppression from the Middle East over thirty years ago and ironically, I’ve chosen to follow the religion they escaped from.
It would be ludicrous to say that my religion doesn’t affect my behavior. Everything from the way I dress to the things I eat are conditioned within Islam. It may not seem like it, but the long sleeves and pants are considered “appropriate” dress for men. Although I eat meat, I try to follow the rules of halal wherever suitable and I keep away from any pork products or alcohol.

August Samie

Unknown said...

I found it interesting August when you wrote "I have met people who claim to be of a certain faith, but don't act according to their supposed belief system."

This reminds me of an idea that was brought up in the lecture I attended on Hinduism and Catholicism. This is the idea of "cafeteria religion", where individuals pick the tenets they like from their religion, while ignoring any teachings they disagree with. I also was raised Catholic, and my observations have shown that many Catholics practice a cafeteria version of Catholicism.

I enjoy philosophy and therefore I enjoy learning about all religions. I travelled to India some years ago to learn more about all religions, but mostly I was interested in Buddhism. For me, I find that Buddhist philosophy resonates the most closely with my own moral and ethical beliefs. For example, I connect with its tenet of following a vegetarian diet. However, I also closesly connect with Jesus' basic teachings of compassion and love for others, and I consider him to be one of the greatest teachers to ever walk the earth.

I know little about Islam except that it is one of the world's great religions with much beauty. Since 9/11, I believe Islam has been greatly misunderstood. Just as there is great disagreement in the Christian faith about how the Bible should be interpreted, I think there is also disagreement within Islam about how the Koran should be interpreted. For example, some fundamentalist Christians use the Bible to justify violence, while others focus on Jesus' teachings and use the Bible to promote peace and nonviolence.

moozishan said...

That must have been an interesting lecture greeneyez!
Personally, i think all religions are prone to misinterpetation of the texts they try to follow because texts are unreliable due to initial oral transmission followed by dictation, copying and translation. It has been all too easy for institutions to justify their existence and behaviour by interpreting ancient texts in a way that suits their purposes, conveniently ignoring the historical conditions when the texts were written and the cultural needs of the times.
Fortunately there are people of all faiths concentrating on common beliefs which can unite rather than divide us. Did the lecture on Catholicism and Hinduism bring out similarities or differences or both ?

Unknown said...

It was a very interesting lecture, indeed.

I would say that the lecture brought out both similarities and differences in the two religions, but it had an underlying feel of acceptance of both religions. I hope we can continue to move in the direction of acceptance towards those who are different from ourselves. Some religions including Catholicism speak of "tolerance" of different faiths. In my opinion, the word "tolerance" does not go far enough in that it implies a sense of putting up with others even though you really do not approve. Webster's defines "tolerance" as "sufferring without complaining". I am in favor of replacing the word "tolerance" with the word "acceptance" in terms of interacting with people who are different than ourselves. This is one of the reasons why I enjoyed the lecture, because of the sense of acceptance and respect for different religions.

Anonymous said...

Namasthe:

What you wrote is very interesting to read. You are indeed a seeker after truth.

Religions are mere aids and they are NOT the final goal.

Spiritual maturity and "self-relization" are the final goals of every human being.

SELF RELIZATION means realizing one is indeed the IMMORTAL SOUL [ATMAN] WITHIN and not the perishable material body.


Since, spirituality has everything to do with TRUTH, a person who is slowly maturing in spirituality will become very CALM and PEACEFUL.

A person who is spiritual, will become egoless , very tolerant and will accept all religions as different paths to ONE AND ONLY GOD.

Ekam Sat, Vipra Bahudha Vadanti

Truth or God is one,
but learned call It by many names

Unknown said...

Thank you for your beautiful and profound comment. Are you the author of the book, Am I A Hindu? If so I feel honored that an esteemed author such as yourself would visit my humble blog, which I mostly do as a hobby that I enjoy. I am interested in your book as I am always interested in learning more about theology. I will pick up a copy for myself. I noticed on your site that you write a lot about yoga, which I am also passionate about.

May all beings everywhere, be happy, healthy, and safe.

Namaste.

Anonymous said...

Namasthe “thrugreeneyes”: Thank you for your very kind words. May God bless you.

I am an engineer by profession and I wrote and published AM I A HINDU? as a part of my own search after truth in 1988.

When I wrote and published, I never ever thought anyone will be interested in a book written by an engineer when thousands of books written by great intellectuals and saints are literally rotting on book shelves around the globe )))……..

But today, after several editions later I can only say, “God you are indeed a miracle worker, through a little “me” you have indeed produced a miracle”

Today I see copies of AM I A HINDU? every where and being translated to many languages.

Many universities in US and Canada are using the book in their world religion classes.

Lately, Dr. Stephen Prothero Chairman of Religious studies, Boston university is recommending every one to read AM I A HINDU?

http://www.usatoday.com/news/religion/2007-03-07-teaching-religion-cover_N.htm?csp=34

I am finding out “Yoga” is one of the best methods, one can slowly come out of “Material Consciousness” and attain “cosmic Consciousness”….

Practicing Yoga helps me to deal with day to day problems very easy.

Here is my article about Yoga.

http://edviswanathan.sulekha.com/blog/post/2006/10/a-bird-s-eye-view-of-yoga-of-east.htm

Please feel free to ask me any question you may have.

aamiahindu@yahoo.com

AnamMandvia said...

Spiritualiy can affect one greatly. Speaking from my own personal beliefs, Islam, shadows my every act. Decisions from the way i eat to the way i dress are taken in accordance to Islam.
Almost all religions have a set of rules, and ethics that effect one's moral. A religon becomes a part of one's character. The only way i believe ones spirituality does not affect them is if they are truly not a believer of a certain religion.

Anonymous said...

In my opinion, a person's spirituality does affect their behavior. They live according to what they belive and most likely will act according to it. It can be either good or bad. There can be a person who is really religous, you may not see them at a club. A lot of religions have their own rules, the way they dress, even the words they use.It affects the behavior in all areas of a person's life.

Carlos said...

I definitely agree that spirituality affects ones behavior. There are people out there who are so religious, that they practically apply everything they do to their religion. In a lot of religions, people believe that their creator is watching them, so they try to do what is right even when no one is looking. There are so many aspects of life that religion affect.

Carlos said...

Surprisingly enough, even diet plays a role in religion. Followers of some religions follow guidelines for their diet like Kosher or Halal. Muslims and Jews have a special way of slaughtering their animals. In some religions, they try to kill the animal with the least amount of suffering. I know Muslims and Jews can't eat certain foods like pork. Some religions have rules like eating in moderation and sharing meals with needy people.